Sales tax for online stores: the basics

Sales tax is one of the topics new sellers worry about most, and for good reason: the rules differ from state to state. This is a general overview of the basics, written to help you ask the right questions. It is not tax or legal advice. For what applies to your business, check with your state tax agency or an accountant.
Who collects sales tax in the US
In the US, sales tax is set by states, and often by counties and cities too. There is no single national sales tax. A seller collects the tax from the customer at checkout and then passes it on to the state. Some states have no state sales tax at all, and local rules can still differ within a state.
That makes two questions important: do you have to collect tax, and in which places?
What nexus means
You generally have to collect sales tax in a state where you have nexus, which means a significant enough connection to that state. Nexus is commonly created in two ways:
- Physical presence. You have a home, a studio, a warehouse, an employee or inventory in the state.
- Economic activity. You sell enough into a state, measured by sales amounts or number of orders. Since a 2018 US Supreme Court decision, states can require out-of-state online sellers to collect tax once they pass their own thresholds.
The thresholds, and what counts toward them, are set by each state, and they change. Many states also require you to register for a sales tax permit before you collect. Which products are taxable can differ too: some states treat food, clothing or digital goods differently from other items. Your state tax agency's website is the best place to check your own situation.
If you also sell on a marketplace, the marketplace may handle tax on those sales. Sales through your own store are your responsibility.
Setting up tax rates in Payly
Payly does not look up tax rates for you. You enter the rates you are required to collect, and checkout adds the tax to the customer's total. You can find the steps in Set up sales tax.
- Go to Settings, then the Shipping & Tax tab, and click Add a tax rate under Tax rates.
- Choose the country, and narrow the rate to a state if the rate applies to one. You can narrow it further by postcode, using an exact postcode, a prefix with a star (such as 902*) or a range.
- Enter the rate as a plain percentage (type 7.25 for 7.25%).
- Add a label, such as "Sales tax".
- Choose whether the tax also applies to shipping.
- Click Save. The rate works at checkout straight away, without publishing.
How Payly picks one rate
Only one rate applies to an order. Payly picks the most specific match: a postcode rate beats a state rate, and a state rate beats a country rate. Rates never add up. If a state tax and a local tax both apply in one place, enter their combined percentage as a single rate. For example, with a 6% rate for the whole United States and a 7.25% rate for California, a California customer pays 7.25%, not 13.25%.
A customer whose address matches none of your rates pays no tax. Tax is added on top of your prices. Payly has no setting for prices that already include tax.
Tax on shipping
Whether shipping is taxable depends on the state and sometimes on how you charge for it. Payly lets you decide for each rate with the "Also charge this tax on shipping" box. Leave it unticked where shipping is not taxed. Items are taxed after any discount code. As an example, a $28.00 item with a 15% code costs $23.80, so a 7.25% rate adds $1.73. If shipping is taxable at a 5% rate, $28.00 of goods plus $15.00 of shipping adds $2.15. Check what applies in your state before you tick the box.
Test it before you go live
With test mode on, add a product to the cart, go to checkout and enter an address for each place where you charge tax. Compare the Tax line with what you expect. Then try an address where you charge no tax. See How tax is shown and charged at checkout.
Reports and record keeping
Good records make filing easier. In Payly, the Tax tab of Dashboard & Analytics shows the tax you collected, by state and by rate, for any period. For a file you can give to an accountant, go to Reports and make a Taxes report for any dates, one country or state, and one payment method. It downloads as a spreadsheet, and you can group it by state or region, tax rate, day, month or each payment. See Download sales, tax and shipping reports.
Every order records the rate it was charged when it was paid, so changing a rate later does not change past figures. The figures come from Payly's records, so compare them with your PayPal, Stripe and other payment records before you file.
What Payly does not do
Payly does not work out what you owe, register you with a state, file returns or pay tax to anyone. You are responsible for your filings and payments. Payly also does not check whether you are required to collect tax in a given state.
Questions
Do I need to collect tax before I register?
Many states want you to register for a permit first. Ask your state tax agency or an accountant before you start charging, and enter the rates in your store once you know what to collect.
Is there a rate I can look up?
Your state tax agency publishes its rates, and many publish local ones too. Payly does not provide a lookup, so use an official source or ask your accountant.
Can I change my rates later?
Yes. You can edit or delete a rate at any time. The change applies to new orders only.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and change over time. Check with your state tax agency or an accountant.


