Square Online vs Payly: which should you pick?

Square and Payly both let you start selling without a monthly bill, but they are built for different jobs. Square began with taking cards in person, and its online store is part of that system. Payly is built for selling online. Here is how the costs compare, and who should pick which.
Square's plans in brief
Square offers a Free plan and two paid plans, priced per location. Online store software is included in each.
| Plan | Monthly price | Online card rate | In-person card rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 3.3% + $0.30 | 2.6% + $0.15 |
| Plus | $49 per location | 2.9% + $0.30 | 2.5% + $0.15 |
| Premium | $149 per location | 2.9% + $0.30 | 2.4% + $0.15 |
Square says the Free plan has no monthly fees or start-up costs, just a processing fee when you make a sale. Plus and Premium have a 30-day free trial. See Square's pricing page.
What the online card rate costs you
The free plan's 3.3% + 30 cents is higher than the standard Stripe rate of 2.9% + 30 cents. It is 0.4 percentage points more, which is small per sale and adds up with volume. On a $50 order:
- Square Free: 3.3% of $50 is $1.65, plus $0.30, so $1.95.
- Square Plus: 2.9% of $50 is $1.45, plus $0.30, so $1.75.
- PayPal Checkout (3.49% + $0.49): about $2.24.
- Stripe standard card: $1.75.
Now stretch it to a month of 100 orders of $50, or $5,000 in sales:
| Option | Processing | Plan | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Square Free | $195 | $0 | $195 |
| Square Plus | $175 | $49 | $224 |
| Payly with Stripe | $175 | $0 | $175 |
On the card rate alone, Square Plus pays for itself only when the 0.4 point saving covers the $49 plan, which happens at about $12,250 a month in online sales. Plus may be worth it for other reasons, but the online rate is not one of them until volume is high.
Where Square is clearly better: selling in person
If you sell at a market, a pop-up, a shop counter or a studio, Square is built for it. Its card readers, point of sale and in-person rates (2.6% + 15 cents on the Free plan) put in-person and online sales in one system. That is a real advantage, and it is the main reason to choose Square.
In Payly, you can record a phone order, a market sale or a bank transfer as an order by hand (see Create an order by hand). An order you create by hand has no payment behind it in PayPal or Stripe, so Payly cannot refund it.
Where Payly fits
Payly is a free ecommerce platform with hosting built in. It charges no monthly fee, no transaction fee and no commission, and every feature is available to every store, with no paid plan to move up to. Customers pay your own PayPal or Stripe account directly, and the only fee on a sale is theirs. Payly is an official PayPal and Stripe partner, and that partnership lets Payly run the platform without charging you.
It offers products with variants, stock tracking, digital downloads, subscriptions and membership levels, discount codes, shipping zones, sales tax rates and downloadable reports. Your store runs on your own free Cloudflare account, which comfortably covers most stores (about 5,000 visitors a day). Connecting your own domain is free, and you pay a registrar for the name, typically about $10 to $20 a year for a .com.
Payments go only through PayPal and Stripe, with one currency per store. Read When and how you get paid to see exactly how the money moves.
Who should pick which
- You sell mostly in person and want an online shop too: Square.
- You want one system for a counter, a market stall and a website: Square.
- You sell only online and want no platform fees at all: Payly.
- You want subscriptions, memberships or digital downloads in your store: Payly.
Selling both ways? Some sellers use Square at the market and a separate online store at home. The two do not have to be the same product, though you will keep two sets of inventory.
Questions
Is Square's free plan really free?
There is no monthly fee. You pay a processing fee on each sale, which is 3.3% + 30 cents online on the Free plan.
How do I take card payments in person with Payly?
Use what your PayPal or Stripe account offers for in-person payments, then record the sale as an order by hand.
Can I try Payly without risking money?
Yes. It is free, and test mode lets you place practice orders through PayPal and Stripe test accounts. To begin, create a free account.
Prices as published by each company for the US in October 2026. Prices can change; check each company's own pricing page.


