Monthly vs yearly subscription pricing: how to offer both

An illustration of a calendar with one date checked and a clock

Most subscription products can be sold monthly, yearly or both. Monthly is easier to say yes to, and yearly is better for cash flow and for keeping customers longer. Offering both lets each customer choose, and it takes one product, not two.

What each option is good for

Monthly has a low commitment. A new customer risks one payment, so it is the easier plan to start with. The downside is that every month is another chance for the customer to cancel or for a card to fail.

Yearly gives you a larger payment up front and removes eleven renewal decisions. A customer who pays yearly has paid for a full year of your product, and you have fewer renewals that can go wrong. The downside is a bigger checkout, which some visitors will not accept until they trust you.

Offering both is usually better than choosing. A visitor who is not ready for a year can still join monthly, and a visitor who is sure can save money by committing.

How to price the yearly option

There is no single right discount. A few things to weigh:

  • Start from the monthly price times twelve. That is what a monthly customer pays over a year, and it is the number your yearly price will be compared with.
  • Give a clear reason to choose yearly. A common approach is to charge for ten or eleven months and give the rest free, or to round down to a tidy figure. Pick something simple enough to explain in one line.
  • Check that it still covers your costs. A discount you cannot afford on a year of service is hard to take back.
  • Keep the gap meaningful but not huge. If yearly is almost free, few people will pay monthly and you give up the flexibility you wanted to offer.

A worked example: a $39.00 monthly plan costs $468.00 over twelve months. A yearly price of $390.00 equals ten months, so a yearly customer saves $78.00. The product page can say "Two months free" without any extra explanation.

PlanPriceCost over 12 months
Monthly$39.00 a month$468.00
Yearly$390.00 a year$390.00

Offering both in one product

In Payly you do not need two products. You sell one subscription and give it plan options, using the same Options and variations section other products use for sizes and colors.

  1. Open your subscription product and set its main price and Bill every to match the monthly plan.
  2. Under Options and variations, add an option called Billing with the values Monthly, Yearly. A row appears for each plan.
  3. In the Yearly row, enter the yearly price, keep the number at 1 and choose Years under Bill every.
  4. Click Save.

The plan names are only labels. The billing schedule comes from the Bill every setting, so a plan called Yearly that is left on months would still bill monthly. Check the period before you save.

Each plan can also have its own free trial and sign-up fee. For example, you could offer a trial on the monthly plan only. Shoppers see the lowest price with the word "From" until they choose a plan, and then the price and schedule update. The full steps are in Offer monthly and yearly plans.

Letting customers switch

Some customers will start monthly and later want the yearly price. If they have to cancel and subscribe again, many will not bother. Payly has a setting for this, called Let customers switch plans, in Settings > Features. It is off until you turn it on, and customers can switch only between the options of the same product.

You decide how a switch is charged:

  • Nothing now. The new price starts at the next payment date. This is the default, and it is the simplest to explain.
  • Charge the difference on upgrades. The customer pays the price difference now for the rest of the period they have paid for.
  • Also credit the unused part of a downgrade. When the new plan costs less per day, the unused part of the old plan is credited against the next payment.

Payly decides whether a switch is an upgrade or a downgrade by comparing the price per day. In the example above, moving from monthly to yearly costs less per day, so it counts as a downgrade, even though the customer is committing to a longer period. PayPal subscriptions always switch at the next renewal, and PayPal asks the customer to approve the change. See Let customers switch plans for the details.

Put the monthly and yearly prices on the product page in your own words, such as "Save $78 a year". Customers compare plans quickly, and a plain saving is easier to understand than a percentage.

Questions

Should the yearly plan be the default?

It depends on your audience. New visitors often prefer the lower first payment. If most of your customers already know your product, you can list yearly first.

Do monthly and yearly customers get the same access?

If you use membership levels, yes. The level belongs to the product, so every plan grants the same level, and a customer who switches plans keeps it.

Is there a fee for offering a yearly plan?

Payly adds none. The only fee on each payment is the standard one charged by PayPal or Stripe, whichever the customer pays with.

The prices in the examples are made up to show the arithmetic. Choose figures that fit your own product.

More from the blog

How to sell printables online

Sell planners, wall art and templates as printables: choose formats and sizes, write a clear license note, build bundles and deliver files after payment.

Squarespace transaction fees explained

Squarespace charges 2% on Basic and 0% above, plus fees on digital content and memberships. See each plan's fees, what Basic leaves out, and examples.

Start selling today, for nothing

Your store, your domain, your payment account, your customers. Set it up in an afternoon. The only thing you pay is normal PayPal and Stripe processing fees.

Start building

No credit card · No paid tier · No trials