The best Etsy alternatives for makers

Etsy is a good place to be found, but its per-listing and per-sale fees add up, and the shop lives on Etsy's site rather than at your own address. If you are weighing options, here are the main alternatives for makers, what each costs, and who each suits. Etsy is not the villain here: for many sellers, it earns its fees.
What Etsy does well
Etsy brings buyers who are already searching for handmade and vintage goods. You do not have to find your own customers on day one, and setting up a shop is quick. The cost is a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee and payment processing of 3% + $0.25 on each sale, plus Offsite Ads fees when an ad leads to a sale. For the full breakdown, see Etsy's fee page.
What Etsy does not give you is your own store: your own address, your own customer relationship, or a design that is entirely yours. That is the main reason makers look elsewhere.
1. Your own store with Payly
Payly is a free ecommerce platform with hosting built in. There is no monthly fee, no transaction fee and no commission, and every feature is available to every store. Customers pay your own PayPal or Stripe account directly, so the only fee on a sale is PayPal's or Stripe's standard processing fee.
Makers get a drag-and-drop editor with ready-made designs, products with variants (sizes, colors and so on, each with its own price, SKU and stock), stock tracking, digital downloads, discount codes, and shipping zones with flat rate, free shipping or local pickup. You can import your Etsy listings from a file, so you do not retype them. See Move from Etsy.
Payly accepts payments only through PayPal and Stripe. To buy shipping labels, connect your own ShipStation account to compare carrier rates and buy labels there. Your store runs on your own free Cloudflare account, and a domain of your own costs about $10 to $20 a year for a .com.
2. Big Cartel
Big Cartel is built around independent artists and makers and keeps things simple. Its Gold plan is free, with 5 products (variations count toward that) and one image each. Gold has no custom domain and no discounts. Platinum is $15 a month ($12 billed yearly) for 50 products and a custom domain, and Diamond is $30 ($24 yearly) for 500 products. Big Cartel charges no transaction fees; sellers use PayPal and Stripe, which charge their own rates.
It suits a small catalog and a seller who wants a quick, uncluttered shop.
3. Shopify
Shopify is the large general-purpose option. Basic is $39 a month, or $29 billed yearly, with unlimited products and a custom domain connection. Shopify offers a 3-day free trial, then $1 a month for 3 months. If customers pay through PayPal or Stripe instead of Shopify Payments, Shopify adds a 2% fee on Basic (PayPal is exempt when Shopify Payments is your primary provider). It makes sense if you expect to grow beyond a single maker's shop and want the widest range of extras.
4. Square Online (free plan)
Square's Free plan costs $0 a month, with an online card rate of 3.3% + 30 cents. Its paid plans start at $49 a month per location and bring the online rate to 2.9% + 30 cents. Square is strongest if you also sell in person at markets and fairs with its card reader, since a single system covers both.
5. Using Etsy alongside your own store
This is often the best answer. Keep Etsy as a discovery channel. Put your best-selling items in your own store, and use packaging inserts, your Etsy bio and email sign-ups to bring repeat buyers to your own address, where you pay no commission. Etsy's own rules apply to how you do this, so read its seller policies before you act.
Side by side
| Option | Monthly cost | Fee on a sale |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy | $0 (Etsy Plus $10) | 6.5% + 3% + $0.25, plus $0.20 per listing |
| Payly | $0 | PayPal or Stripe only |
| Big Cartel | $0, $15 or $30 | PayPal or Stripe only |
| Shopify | $29 to $39 (Basic) | Card fee, plus 2% with PayPal or Stripe |
| Square Free | $0 | 3.3% + $0.30 online |
How to choose
- No audience yet: stay on Etsy for now, and build your own store in parallel.
- Selling in person too: look at Square.
- Small catalog and a simple shop: Big Cartel's free plan is a fair start.
- Many products, variants, subscriptions or digital downloads, with no platform fees: Payly.
- Planning a large business: Shopify.
Questions
Can I move my Etsy listings to my own store?
Yes. Download your listings from Etsy as a file and import them into Payly. See Import products from another store.
Will I lose my Etsy sales if I open my own store?
No. Etsy and your own store can run side by side.
Prices as published by each company for the US in October 2026. Prices can change; check each company's own pricing page.


