How to choose an ecommerce platform: what to compare

An illustration of two lists side by side, one fully checked

Choosing an ecommerce platform is easier when you compare the same five things on every option: total cost, fees on each sale, the features you need, how easily you can leave, and where your store is hosted. This guide explains each, then puts the main options in one table.

1. Total cost, not the headline price

A platform's advertised price is rarely what you pay. Count the monthly plan, any plan upgrade you will need for features like discount codes, a custom domain, paid add-ons, and hosting if the platform does not include it. Then multiply by twelve and divide by the orders you expect. A $39 plan sounds small until it is 40 orders a month.

Also check billing terms. Several platforms show a lower monthly price when you pay for a year up front, and a higher price when you pay month by month.

2. Fees on each sale

Payment processing is unavoidable. PayPal and Stripe each charge their own standard rates, which are the same whichever platform you use. What differs is whether the platform adds a second fee on top. For example, Shopify charges a third-party transaction fee when you do not use its own payments, and Etsy charges a transaction fee plus a listing fee. Squarespace's Basic plan carries a 2% fee on store sales. Some platforms, including Wix, BigCommerce with PayPal or Stripe, and Big Cartel, add none.

On a $50 order, a 2% platform fee is $1.00. Over 500 orders, that is $500 you could have kept.

3. Features you need on day one

Make a short list of what you cannot launch without: variants for sizes and colors, discount codes, digital downloads, subscriptions, shipping rules by region, sales tax rates, a way to refund. Then check that each is on the plan you would actually buy. Some platforms reserve features for higher plans. Squarespace's Basic plan, for instance, lacks discount codes and carrier-calculated shipping.

Be just as clear about what you do not need. If you take card payments in a physical shop, you need point-of-sale hardware.

4. Ownership and the way out

Ask three questions before you commit:

  • Can I export my products to a file?
  • Can I use my own domain on the plan I would buy?
  • Who holds my customer payments, my store files and my data?

Shopify, WooCommerce, Wix and Squarespace all offer product export to a file, though each has limits, such as Wix not exporting digital products. Payly exports your products as a Shopify or WooCommerce file, and can import from Shopify, Etsy, Wix, Squarespace and WooCommerce, so moving in or out does not mean retyping a catalog.

5. Hosting

Most hosted platforms include hosting in the plan. WooCommerce does not: the software is free, but WooCommerce estimates hosting at $25 to $350 a month for most stores, plus maintenance and updates. Payly runs your store on your own free Cloudflare account, which comfortably covers most stores, about 5,000 visitors a day. If a store ever outgrows it, Cloudflare's paid plan is $5 a month, paid to Cloudflare.

The main options side by side

PlatformCheapest plan that sells onlineExtra fee on salesWorth knowing
Payly$0, no paid planNone from Payly. PayPal or Stripe fees onlyPayPal and Stripe only. One currency per store
ShopifyBasic $39 a month, or $29 billed yearly2% on Basic if you do not use Shopify Payments (1% Grow, 0.6% Advanced, 0.2% Plus). PayPal is exempt only when Shopify Payments is your main provider3-day free trial, then $1 a month for 3 months. Shopify Payments is 2.9% + 30 cents on Basic
WixCore $36 a month, or $29 billed yearlyNone from WixThe Free and Light plans cannot take payments
SquarespaceBasic $25 a month, or $19 billed yearly2% on Basic, 0% on Core ($39/$29) and above14-day free trial. Basic lacks discount codes
BigCommerceCore $39 a month, or $29 billed yearlyNone for PayPal or StripeMoves to Growth ($105/$79) above $30,000 in yearly sales. 15-day trial
WooCommerceFree plugin, plus hostingNone from WooCommerceHosting estimated at $25 to $350 a month. Official extensions $29 to $299 a year each
SquareFree plan, $0Online card rate 3.3% + 30 cents on FreePlus is $49 a month and Premium $149 a month, with 2.9% + 30 cents online
Big CartelGold, $0 (5 products)None. No transaction feesPlatinum $15 a month ($12 yearly) for 50 products and a custom domain
EtsyNo plan. $0.20 per listing6.5% transaction fee plus 3% + $0.25 processingA marketplace with built-in shoppers, but you cannot use your own domain for the shop

No single row is best for everyone. Shopify offers a wide choice of plans. WooCommerce gives you total control if you are comfortable managing hosting. Etsy brings its own shoppers. Payly suits sellers who want a full store, with variants, subscriptions, memberships and downloads, without a monthly bill or a cut of sales. The full list of what is included is in What does Payly cost?.

Questions

Which platform is cheapest?

Cheapest depends on your volume and the features you need. Compare total cost at the number of orders you expect, including fees on sales. Payly has no platform fee, so its cost comes only from payment processing.

Is it hard to switch later?

It is easier if your platform exports products to a file. Check this before you choose. If you are coming from another store, see how to switch to Payly.

Should I start on a marketplace?

A marketplace can help you find first buyers, and you can run your own store beside it. Just remember that marketplace shoppers belong to the marketplace, while a store of your own gives you a customer list you control. You can try Payly for free and decide later.

Prices as published by each company for the US in October 2026. Prices can change; check each company's own pricing page.

More from the blog

Start selling today, for nothing

Your store, your domain, your payment account, your customers. Set it up in an afternoon. The only thing you pay is normal PayPal and Stripe processing fees.

Start building

No credit card · No paid tier · No trials