Free trials vs sign-up fees for subscriptions: which should you use?

An illustration of a small box inside two circling arrows

When you sell a subscription, the first payment is the hardest one to earn. A free trial makes joining feel safe, and a sign-up fee makes sure the first month pays for itself. They solve different problems, and you can use either one, or both together.

What each one does

A free trial is a period at the start of a subscription when the customer is not charged. The regular price starts when the trial ends.

A sign-up fee is a one-time charge when the customer joins, on top of the regular price. It is not repeated at renewal.

The first removes a barrier for the customer. The second adds income for you. Which one helps depends on what stands between a visitor and a purchase.

When a free trial makes sense

A trial works best when people cannot tell whether they will like the product until they have used it. Some examples:

  • Access products. A members-only video library, a recipe club or a studio pass. Browsing is easier than explaining.
  • Products with a habit attached. If a customer has to build a routine first, a week or two gives them time to do it.
  • Higher monthly prices. The more a subscription costs, the more a visitor wants to try before paying.

A trial costs you something too. Anyone who joins and leaves before the first payment gives you no revenue, and if the product ships physical goods, you may have sent something for free. Keep trials short (a week is common) unless the product really needs longer.

When a sign-up fee makes sense

A sign-up fee fits when joining costs you real time or money up front:

  • A welcome kit, a starter box or a tote bag sent to every new member.
  • Onboarding work, such as a first consultation or setting up an account by hand.
  • A product where you want committed customers, not people who sign up for a single month and leave.

The trade-off is that any extra charge at checkout is one more reason to hesitate. Say clearly what the fee covers, and if there is a welcome item, show it on the product page.

Using both together

The two settings do not cancel each other out. In Payly, the sign-up fee is charged at checkout even during a free trial. That gives you a useful middle path: the customer commits a small amount now, and the full price waits until the trial ends.

Here is a worked example with a $39.00 monthly subscription, a 7-day free trial and a $10.00 sign-up fee:

SetupPaid at checkoutThen
Trial and fee$10.00$39.00 after 7 days, then monthly
Trial only$0.00$39.00 after 7 days, then monthly
Fee only$49.00 (fee plus first month)$39.00 monthly
Neither$39.00$39.00 monthly

Amounts are before any tax or shipping. A small fee with a trial also filters out some people who would not have stayed anyway. Whether that helps you is something only your own numbers can show.

How to set them up in Payly

Both settings live on the subscription product. Open the product, scroll to the Subscription / membership section, enter a Free trial length and a Trial unit (days, weeks, months or years), and enter a Sign-up fee. Leave either one empty to skip it. Customers see both on the product page.

A few details are worth knowing:

  • Customers still enter their payment details at checkout during a trial. The regular price is not charged until the trial ends, and checkout shows the date of the first payment.
  • During a trial, the subscription shows as On trial in your Subscriptions list with the date the trial ends.
  • PayPal sends no notice before a trial ends. For Stripe subscriptions, Payly emails the customer a reminder three days before the trial turns into a charge.
  • A subscription that ships cannot charge shipping on the first payment only while it has a trial. Choose shipping on every payment instead.
  • If you offer monthly and yearly plans, each plan can have its own trial and fee. A blank box uses the product's setting, and 0 removes it for that plan.
  • A discount code can be limited to sign-up fees, or can leave them at full price, using its Applies to setting.

The steps are in Free trials and sign-up fees. If you have not made a subscription product yet, start with Sell a subscription product. Payly takes no commission on the payments, so the only fee on each one is PayPal's or Stripe's standard processing fee.

Try the whole flow in test mode before you open the store. Place an order yourself and check what checkout shows under Recurring totals, so you know exactly what your customers will see.

Questions

Should I offer a trial on a low-priced subscription?

Often it is not needed. If the monthly price is small, the risk to the customer is already small, and a trial mostly adds work for you. A trial matters more as the price rises.

How long should a trial be?

Long enough for a customer to see the value, and no longer. A week suits many products. A product that people use once a month needs a longer trial, or may suit a first-month discount code instead.

Can customers cancel during a trial?

By default, yes. Customers can cancel or pause from My account, and you can switch either option off in Settings > Features. Make the trial terms clear on the product page so there are no surprises when the first payment arrives.

The amounts in the examples are made up to show the arithmetic. Choose figures that fit your own costs and prices.

More from the blog

Start selling today, for nothing

Your store, your domain, your payment account, your customers. Set it up in an afternoon. The only thing you pay is normal PayPal and Stripe processing fees.

Start building

No credit card · No paid tier · No trials